Power of Attorney vs. Guardianship – Understanding the Differences and Making the Right Decision

28 September 2023

Planning for the unexpected is essential, especially when it comes to matters of legal responsibility for property, finances, and medical decisions. It’s not something that people like to think about, but it’s important to understand the difference between power of attorney and guardianship. In this blog post, we will break down what each of these terms means, the pros and cons of each, and why an attorney can help you make the right decision.


What is Power of Attorney?

Power of attorney is a legal document that authorizes someone to act on your behalf when it comes to financial or medical decisions. The person giving the power is called the principal, and the person receiving the power is called the agent or attorney-in-fact. The agent can be given broad or limited power, and it can be effective immediately or upon incapacity, which is a term defined in the document. It is important to note that power of attorney does not take away the principal’s decision-making authority. They can still make decisions for themselves, and as long as they are able, they can revoke the power of attorney at any time.


What is Guardianship?

Guardianship is a legal proceeding where a court appoints someone to make decisions for a person who has been found to be incapacitated. The person who needs help is called the ward, and the person appointed by the court is called the guardian. Guardianship is typically used for older adults who have dementia or other cognitive impairments, but it can also be used for younger people with disabilities. The guardian can be given the authority to make decisions about the ward’s finances, property, and medical care. Unlike power of attorney, guardianship takes away the ward’s decision-making authority, and the ward’s rights are limited to the extent authorized by the court.


What is the Difference?

The main difference between power of attorney and guardianship is the level of decision-making authority. With power of attorney, the principal retains their decision-making authority and can revoke the power at any time. With guardianship, the ward’s decision-making authority is taken away, and they may not be able to regain it. In addition, guardianship is typically more restrictive than power of attorney, as the court is involved and has control over the decisions made.


What are the Pros and Cons for Both?

Power of attorney is generally less expensive and less restrictive than guardianship, and it can be effective immediately. However, it is important to choose a trusted agent, and there is a risk of abuse of power. Guardianship is more secure and can provide more oversight, but it can also be more expensive and restrictive. Additionally, it can be difficult to navigate the court system and may take time to establish.


What is the Least Restrictive Alternative?

The least restrictive alternative is a legal principle that requires the option that is the least restrictive on the ward’s autonomy to be chosen. This means that if power of attorney is a sufficient alternative to guardianship, it should be used instead. It is important to ensure that the ward’s autonomy is not unnecessarily limited, and all options should be explored before deciding on guardianship.


How Can an Attorney Help?

An attorney can help you understand the options available to you, draft the necessary legal documents, and navigate the court system if necessary. They can review your specific situation and advise you on the best course of action for your needs. An attorney can also act as a neutral third party and ensure that the principal or ward’s best interests are being protected.


At RISM LLC, we can assist the Washington, DC public with power of attorney services. Our experienced attorneys can guide you through the process and help you make the right decision for your unique situation.


In summary, understanding the differences between power of attorney and guardianship is important when planning for the unexpected. Both options have their pros and cons, and it is crucial to choose the least restrictive alternative while still protecting the principal or ward’s best interests. Consulting with an attorney can help ensure that you make the right decision for your needs. At RISM LLC, we are here to help the Washington, DC public with all their power of attorney needs.

by Martha C. White 12 May 2025
People over 65 who remarry after a death or divorce can face thorny financial questions — especially when it comes to adult children and inheritances.
by Tammy LaGorce 3 May 2025
Although a will is crucial to making sure your assets go where you want them when you die, you are likely to need something else, too: designated beneficiaries.
by Ann Carrns 27 September 2024
A call from a debt collector may add to the challenges that bereaved people are already dealing with. But spouses “should not assume that they have to pay.”
by Shaina Feinberg and Julia Rothman 17 June 2024
Then I talked to some end-of-life experts. Here’s what I found out.
by Martha C. White 8 June 2024
Older people who stash large sums of cash in their homes think it’s safer there than anyplace else. But they could be creating huge headaches for their heirs.
by Lisa Rabasca Roepe 18 May 2024
A sudden windfall while grieving can be an emotional minefield, particularly for younger adults. Experts share ways to handle it wisely.
There is a statue of justice in the background and a wooden gavel in the foreground.
30 April 2024
Dealing with the passing of a loved one is never easy, and matters can become even more complicated when it comes to handling their estate. Estate litigation can be a complex and emotionally draining process that requires expert legal guidance to ensure your rights are protected. If you are a Washington DC resident facing estate litigation, hiring an experienced attorney is essential. In this blog post, we will discuss the importance of having a skilled estate litigation attorney by your side to navigate through this challenging time.
A judge 's gavel is sitting on top of a black table.
28 March 2024
Understanding the Importance of Estate Planning in Washington DC
A close up of a wooden judge 's gavel on a wooden table.
18 February 2024
Starting a business is an exciting venture - you have a great idea, you're passionate about it, and you're ready to take the world by storm. However, before you can start marketing your product or service, there's some legal groundwork that needs to be laid. This is where a business formation attorney comes in. In this blog post, we'll discuss why every Washington DC business needs a business formation attorney and what services they offer to help ensure your success.
View More Blogs